Dry cough and breathlessness in a woman on methotrexate
A pharmacovigilance case for causality assessment: work out which drug is responsible, grade the reaction's severity and seriousness, and defend a causality category using the Naranjo probability scale.
Naranjo probability scale
- Framework
- Naranjo probability scale
- You decide
- Suspect drug, reaction, severity, seriousness, causality
The case
A 55-year-old woman presented to the respiratory clinic with a two-week history of dry cough and progressive breathlessness. She had been diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis six months earlier. Four months ago, she was started on methotrexate 15 mg once weekly and folic acid 5 mg daily. Three months ago, hydroxychloroquine 200 mg daily was added. Two weeks ago, she developed a dry cough and noticed that she became short of breath after walking up one flight of stairs. Over the last few days, her breathlessness has worsened, and she is now breathless on minimal exertion. On examination, she was tachypnoeic with a respiratory rate of 28 breaths per minute, and she had fine crepitations bilaterally in the lung bases. Her oxygen saturation was 91% on room air. She had small joint swan neck deformities consistent with long-standing rheumatoid arthritis. Chest radiograph showed bilateral interstitial infiltrates, and high-resolution CT confirmed bilateral ground-glass opacities with a predominantly basal distribution. Blood tests showed a slightly raised white cell count with no eosinophilia, an elevated CRP of 45 mg/L, and normal renal and liver function. Sputum microscopy and culture were negative, and viral PCR for common respiratory viruses was negative. She was admitted for supplemental oxygen and supportive care. Her regular medications were continued, but the methotrexate was withheld. Within 72 hours, her respiratory symptoms began to improve, and by day seven, her oxygen saturation was 96% on room air. Repeat chest imaging at day seven showed partial resolution of the infiltrates. No rechallenge was undertaken.
What you are asked to do
- Identify which of the patient's drugs is the suspect, and say why the others are not.
- Name the reaction and grade its severity.
- Decide whether it is serious by regulatory criteria, which is not the same as severe.
- Assign a causality category under the Naranjo probability scale and justify it from the timeline, the dechallenge and the alternative causes.
- State the management and what should be reported.
The suspect drug and the graded answer are deliberately not on this page: working them out is the exercise.
Log in to assess "Dry cough and breathlessness in a woman on methotrexate"
A free account opens the trainer: name the suspect drug, grade the reaction and commit to a causality category, then see how your assessment compares and why.
More like this
- Euglycaemic ketoacidosis after fasting in a 58-year-old man with diabetes
- Fever and rigors nine days after the first cycle of chemotherapy
- Fever, facial swelling and rash after starting allopurinol in a 70-year-old man
- Fever, rigidity and confusion in a 28-year-old man
- Flushing, pruritus and hypotension during a rapid intravenous vancomycin infusion in a 45-year-old man
- Fresh rectal bleeding and haemoglobin drop in a 70-year-old man on rivaroxaban and naproxen
Educational content for students and clinicians in training. It does not replace professional judgement, local protocols or current prescribing information.